---
title: "Are Carbs Bad for Weight Loss? Why Most Women I See Need More, Not Less"
entity: "blog"
canonical_url: "https://www.alexatorontow.com/blog/are-carbs-bad-for-weight-loss"
markdown_url: "https://www.alexatorontow.com/llms/blog/are-carbs-bad-for-weight-loss"
lastmod: "2026-11-19T11:27:06.000Z"
---

If you grew up in the 80s or 90s, you probably learned one rule about weight loss before you learned anything else: cut the carbs. It's normal to feel nervous about bread, pasta or rice when you're trying to lose weight. That message was everywhere, and for a lot of us it never really left.

So, are carbs bad for weight loss?

For most women I work with, no. In fact, they're usually not eating enough of them.

Let's dive into what I see in practice, what carbs actually do in your body, and how to figure out what you need.

## What I see when I look at my patients' nutrition

Over the past year, I've shifted most of my practice to weight loss, and the thing that has surprised me most is how often my patients are under-fuelling.

The pattern I see over and over is low carbohydrates, low protein and high fat.

This isn't a willpower problem. It's what happens after years of trying to "be good" by skipping the bread and reaching for a handful of nuts or a cheese plate instead. Fat creeps up, carbs and protein drop, and you end up tired, hungry and frustrated that the scale isn't moving.

## Why I start with just two days of tracking

I'm not a fan of tracking forever, and I don't want you measuring every teaspoon for the rest of your life. But I've found that an objective starting point changes everything.

Most of my patients begin by tracking what they eat for just two days: one weekday and one weekend day.

Why bother? Because without a baseline, advice like "eat more protein" or "add more fibre" is guesswork. You don't know where you're starting, so you can't tell whether a change is working. That uncertainty is where a lot of people give up.

Two days of real data takes the guessing out. We can see exactly what's missing and where to start, and in my experience that gets people results much faster.

## What carbs actually do in your body

Carbs have had a terrible PR team. Here's what they actually do.

### Your muscles are the biggest users of glucose

When you eat carbohydrates, they're broken down into glucose. Your muscles are the largest consumers of that glucose, taking up roughly 70 to 90 percent of the glucose from a meal.

That's an important shift in thinking. Carbs aren't just sitting around waiting to be stored as fat. A large share goes straight to the tissue you're trying to build and keep.

### Glycogen is your muscles' fuel tank

Your muscles store carbohydrate as glycogen. Think of it as a fuel tank for movement.

Strength training draws that tank down. It doesn't usually empty it the way a long endurance run can, but it does lower it. Research has shown that having carbohydrates on board before or during resistance training can improve performance, and that topping up carbs between two training sessions on the same day helps the second session go better.

Is it always strictly necessary? Not always. It depends on what you're measuring, whether that's your one-rep max or how many reps you can do in a session. But as a general rule, fuelling before training, strength or cardio, is a good idea for most people.

### Running on empty affects more than your workout

When glycogen runs low for too long, it can affect your overall energy availability and the normal rhythm of your hormones. That's one reason chronic under-fuelling can leave you feeling flat, wired or stuck, even when you feel like you're doing everything right.

### Protein alone isn't enough

Here's the nuance I care about most. If you eat enough protein but keep your carbs low, you may be able to hold on to muscle, but your performance will likely suffer. And if you can't train well, it's much harder to build strength and lean muscle mass, which is one of the best things you can do for your metabolism and for keeping weight off long term.

For people who train a lot (more than about eight hours a week), research supports a high-carbohydrate intake for maintaining muscle and recovering well. Most of us aren't training at that level, but the principle holds: muscles that are working need fuel.

## It goes far beyond weight loss

I'll share my own experience. Over this past year, I've doubled my daily carbohydrate intake, and I'm in the best shape of my life. I'm stronger, leaner and lifting more than ever, and my visceral fat is the lowest it's been.

But the changes that surprised me most had nothing to do with body composition. I'm sleeping through the night. My anxiety is lower, my mood is steadier, my energy holds up through the afternoon and my blood sugar feels more balanced.

I've worked with hundreds of people this year, and I've lost count of how many times we've increased someone's carbs and they've felt better, recovered better, lifted more and lost weight.

Everyone is different, and this isn't a promise of a specific result. It is a strong reason to stop assuming carbs are the problem.

## So what is usually the problem?

In my experience, it's rarely carbs on their own. It's usually too much of one thing or not nearly enough of another, most often too much fat and not enough protein or carbohydrates.

A few places to start:

- Get a baseline. Track two days, one weekday and one weekend day, so you know where you actually are.
- Look at the balance, not just the total. Notice how your carbs, protein and fat compare to each other.
- Fuel your training. Have some carbohydrates in the hours before you work out, especially before strength training.
- Choose carbs that work for you. Fruit, potatoes, rice, oats, whole grains and legumes all count, and so does the occasional holiday treat.

## Heading into the holidays

This time of year, a lot of women go into the season bracing themselves: avoiding the bread basket, skipping the potatoes and feeling guilty about dessert. I'd love for you to try something different this year.

Carbs aren't the enemy. It doesn't have to be restrictive to be effective.

## You don't have to figure this out alone

If you'd like to know what your own baseline looks like and what to change first, I'd love to help. I see patients in person in Calgary and virtually across Alberta.

[Book a free 15-minute call](https://novacliniccalgary.janeapp.com/locations/nova-naturopathic-clinic-consults-therapies/book#/staff_member/45/treatment/924)

You are not meant to walk this alone.

Dr. Alexa Torontow, ND
